Which is better - forceps or vacuum delivery?
Instrumental delivery refers to the use of the Vacuum or Forceps instrument to assist the delivery of your baby. Instrumental delivery is actually an aid to facilitate
natural birth. Your cervix needs to be fully dilated (10 cm) before either instrument can be used. Your doctor will decide which instrument is more suitable for you and the baby.
Your doctor will gently apply two sterile instruments (forceps blades) into your vagina around the baby’s head. The instruments look like curved spoon-shaped tongs, and are specially designed to fit comfortably around the baby’s head. As you push during each uterine contraction, your doctor will deliver the baby’s head using the forceps blades.
Your doctor places an instrument called a vacuum extractor on the baby’s scalp. The vacuum extractor looks like a cup. A vacuum is then gently created using a pump. As you push with each uterine contraction, your doctor will gently pull so that your baby’s head is delivered using the vacuum extractor. There are many forms of vacuum extractors available but the most commonly used one is the ‘Kiwi cup’.
There are also a number of reasons why it may be necessary for you to have an assisted delivery (forceps/vacuum delivery) during your second stage of labour (i.e. when the cervix is fully opened).
episiotomy may be required when the vacuum or forceps is used.
There are actually very few instances where an instrumental delivery should be avoided. The following is a list of clinical scenarios where a
Cesarean section may be a better option:
There are certain prerequisites that must be present before an instrumental delivery can be carried out.
It has to be stressed that most of the assisted deliveries are uneventful and will be performed with you and your baby’s interests in mind. This will only be carried out if it is felt that you will be able to deliver safely through the vagina.
However, some of the possible problems include:
If an episiotomy was done, you will need some stitches (read
the article on Pushing and delivery: Is an episiotomy needed?).
Occasionally, your doctor may insert an indwelling catheter to help “rest your bladder” for a day or two till your discomfort reduces.
Although these instruments may be used under similar conditions, your obstetrician will choose the instrument most appropriate to the clinical circumstance and personal preference.
It has to be stressed that most of the assisted deliveries are uneventful and will be performed with you and your baby’s interests in mind. This will only be carried out if it is felt that can deliver vaginally safely. A cesarean section performed under these circumstances may be more risky at a late stage of labour.
It is important to follow the doctor’s instructions closely during instrumental delivery. You should relax and not bear down when the instrument is inserted into your vagina and applied to the baby’s head. Similarly, you should push well when asked to do so. This is when you are experiencing a contraction. During a contraction, when you are pushing, your doctor will assist you with the forceps or vacuum to deliver the baby’s head.
Sometimes, if your doctor attempts an assisted delivery and the baby cannot be delivered safely, you will need an emergency cesarean section.
You would also be required to sign on the appropriate consent forms once the decision for an instrumental delivery is made.
Source: Dr TAN Thiam Chye, Dr TAN Kim Teng, Dr TAN Heng Hao, Dr TEE Chee Seng John, The New Art and Science of Pregnancy and Childbirth, World Scientific 2008.
Visit Parent Hub, for more useful tips and guides for a healthy pregnancy.
Download the HealthHub app on
Google Play or
Apple Store to access more health and wellness advice at your fingertips.
This article was last reviewed on
22 Nov 2023
The ABCs of Health Screening
Delicious Diabetes Friendly Recipes - Eat Well, Live Well
Hidden Sugars and Diabetes
Plan Your Meals with My Healthy Plate
Screening Tests That Are Useful to Some People Only (Category 2 Tests)
View More Programmes
Find out more about pre-diabetes, diabetes and how you can prevent them by making some changes to your lifestyle.
Subsidised health screening for Singapore Citizens.
Come explore 3 easy-to-remember ways to manage diabetes and lead a fulfilling life.
Browse Live Healthy
In partnership with